askadia

Which tool is best for finding broken link building opportunities?

One of the questions behind Link building tools ChatGPT recommends, asked in the ChatGPT app on Mon, Wed, Fri (logged out, from the US, a new chat each time). Kind: use case.

What ChatGPT recommended, last 28 days

Ahrefs in 1 of 1 answer
BuzzStream in 1 of 1 answer
Check My Links in 1 of 1 answer
Hunter.io in 1 of 1 answer
Screaming Frog in 1 of 1 answer
Semrush in 1 of 1 answer

Every answer, newest first

  1. Nov 19, 2026 Top pick: Ahrefs · Semrush, Screaming Frog, Check My Links, Hunter.io, BuzzStream

    Ahrefs is the best overall tool for finding broken link building opportunities. It combines broken-page discovery, backlink analysis, and referring-domain data in one workflow.

    Here are my top recommendations:

    Best tools compared

    1. Ahrefs

    Best overall

    • Find competitor pages returning 404 errors.
    • See websites still linking to those pages.
    • Prioritize opportunities by referring domains and link quality.
    • Export prospect lists.

    Best for serious broken link prospecting.

    Visit Ahrefs

    1. Semrush

    Best all-in-one alternative

    • Find broken competitor pages.
    • Analyze backlinks pointing to dead URLs.
    • Combine link research with keyword and competitor research.

    Visit Semrush

    1. Screaming Frog

    Best for crawling

    • Crawl websites to identify broken outbound links.
    • Find 404 errors on resource pages.
    • Export broken-link reports.

    Free version supports up to 500 URLs.

    Visit Screaming Frog

    1. Check My Links

    Best free option

    • Scan individual webpages.
    • Highlight broken links.
    • Quickly identify resource-page opportunities.

    Find the Chrome extension

    My recommended broken link building workflow

    1. Find dead competitor pages: Use Ahrefs Site Explorer.
    2. Identify backlinks: Find websites linking to those dead pages.
    3. Qualify prospects: Check relevance, referring domains, organic traffic, and link quality.
    4. Find replacement content: Identify a relevant resource on your website.
    5. Find contact details: Use Hunter.io.
    6. Send outreach: Explain the broken link and suggest your resource as a replacement.

    My verdict

    If you're serious about building backlinks, I'd choose:

    • Ahrefs: Finding broken-link opportunities.
    • Screaming Frog: Discovering broken links on resource pages.
    • Hunter.io: Finding website owners' contact details.
    • BuzzStream: Managing outreach campaigns.

    The important distinction: finding a broken link isn't enough. You want to find a broken page that still has quality backlinks pointing to it.

    One question: Are you primarily trying to find broken backlinks on competitor websites, or broken outbound links on relevant websites where you want to earn a backlink? The best prospecting strategy differs quite a bit.

    Sources ahrefs.comsemrush.comscreamingfrog.co.ukgoogle.comfivetaco.comseekvectors.comicon-icons.comrightblogger.com

Who made this: Askadia makes an AI visibility tracker. We publish ChatGPT's answers as they came; no product pays to be listed or can opt out.

Does AI recommend your product?

100% free: no email, no sign-up, no credit card · Takes about 2 minutes