Guides · Updated November 14, 2026
How to rank in Google AI Mode: one list was behind half its answers (240 answers, 40 questions)
The short answer: Google AI Mode reads few pages, about 3 an answer, and leans on the same one or two. Asked 40 buying questions about AI visibility tools, twice, it cited one list, Zapier's best AI visibility tools, in 38 of its 80 answers, and when it did, it recommended that list's picks: ZipTie in 27 of those 38 answers, and in none of the 42 that didn't cite it. On the same questions, it came and went with the list. So to rank in AI Mode, find the pages it cites for your buyers' questions and get onto them. ChatGPT and AI Overviews work differently.
What we measured
We track one category in public: AI visibility tools, 40 buying questions written the way buyers ask (broad ones, use cases, team sizes, budgets, integrations), published with every answer. We asked each one in the ChatGPT app, as a Google search (reading its AI Overview) and in Google AI Mode, logged out, in the US, on November 11 and again on November 13, 2026: 240 answers, 80 per assistant.
- Cited: the answer lists the page among its sources.
- Recommended: the answer offers the product as a pick or an option, not just a mention in passing.
- Askadia is one of the tools in this category, so we say where it stands: none of the three recommended it in round 1, and it isn't on Zapier's list.
AI Mode leans on one list
AI Mode cited 2.7 pages an answer, against 5.6 for AI Overviews and 7.3 for ChatGPT, and they were the same few: Zapier's list in 38 of 80 answers, then two Reddit threads (12 and 10). When an answer cited Zapier's list, it recommended the list's picks far more often:
| Recommended in AI Mode | Answers citing Zapier's list | Answers not citing it |
|---|---|---|
| ZipTie | 27 of 38 | 0 of 42 |
| Similarweb | 13 of 38 | 0 of 42 |
| Semrush | 37 of 38 | 15 of 42 |
| Ahrefs Brand Radar | 29 of 38 | 15 of 42 |
It held in both rounds: 18 of 40 answers cited the list on November 11 (ZipTie in 10 of them, none of the other 22), 20 of 40 on November 13 (ZipTie in 17, none of the other 20). ChatGPT, reading the same web, didn't put ZipTie or Similarweb among the tools it recommends most.
Is it just the questions?
The obvious objection: maybe the questions that pull in Zapier's list are the ones that would recommend ZipTie anyway. So we compared each question with itself. On 12 questions, AI Mode cited the list in one round and not in the other:
- ZipTie: recommended in 9 of 12 answers that cited the list, and in 0 of the 12 answers to the same questions that didn't.
- Semrush: 12 of 12 against 5 of 12.
- Ahrefs Brand Radar, which most lists include: 7 of 12 against 6 of 12, about the same.
Same question, same week, the list in or out, and ZipTie in or out with it. It's 12 questions in one category over two rounds, so read it as strong evidence, not proof; we'll add rounds as they come in.
Reddit threads work the same way
The two Reddit threads AI Mode cited most did the same for the tools named in them. A thread on r/AI_Agents about tracking brand mentions brought in Slate: recommended in 4 of the 10 answers that cited it and in none of the other 70 (3 of 6 against 0 of 6 on the same questions). A guide on r/SaaS did it for Evertune: 5 of 12 against 1 of 68. One thread, a few comments, and a small tool appears in Google's AI answers.
ChatGPT and AI Overviews don't
- ChatGPT reads widely and names the consensus. Its most-cited page, TechnologyAdvice's guide, was in only 10 of 80 answers. On the same questions, citing it or not barely changed who was recommended (Profound 8 of 8 against 6 of 8; Peec AI 7 of 8 against 6 of 8). One page won't swing ChatGPT; being on many will.
- AI Overviews read what ranks on Google. 130 of the 192 sites they cited on November 13 were in Google's own top 10 for the same search. YouTube videos were cited in 37 of 80 answers and Zapier's list in 20. The pull of any one page was weaker than in AI Mode: on the same questions, Google Search Console was recommended in 4 of 7 answers citing Straight North's list against 1 of 7 without.
- They rarely agree. On November 13 the three gave the same top pick on at most 1 of the 40 questions, and two assistants' lists for one question had 21–29% of their tools in common.
Our own products on AI Mode
We track our products on all three too. The week to November 13, counted in questions (a question counts when most of its answers name the product; SocialPhotos' Google numbers rest on one answer per question):
| Product | ChatGPT | Google AI Overviews | Google AI Mode |
|---|---|---|---|
| PodSeeker (25 questions) | named in 23 | named in 19 | named in 12 |
| SocialPhotos (22 questions) | named in 15 | named in 8 | named in 7 |
Both do worst on AI Mode. Which few pages it reads for their questions is what we're checking next, with the same method. More in How to rank in ChatGPT.
How to rank in Google AI Mode
- Find the pages it cites for your buyers' questions. Ask each question in AI Mode, logged out, more than once, and note the sources. Expect a short list: one or two “best X” articles and a few Reddit threads, the same across many questions.
- Get onto those pages. Lists like these are updated every few months; write to the author with what you'd add for their readers, and what you don't do. A placement on the one list AI Mode leans on is worth more than ten it never reads. We ask and never pay for a place.
- Take part in the threads it cites. Answer the question asked, say who you are, and only where your product fits.
- Keep the basics: AI Mode starts from Google's index, so a page that doesn't rank or isn't indexed won't be read. For AI Overviews that's most of it: rank on Google, and on YouTube for the same search.
- Don't judge AI Mode by ChatGPT. Track each assistant on its own; recommended on one says little about another.
Askadia does step 1 on a schedule: it asks your buyers' questions on ChatGPT, AI Overviews and AI Mode, and shows for each assistant who it recommended and the pages it cited, every answer in full, so you see which lists matter for you, and whether getting onto one moved anything. 2,000 answers a month for $29, with an API and MCP server for your coding agent.
Questions
Is Google AI Mode the same as AI Overviews?
No. AI Overviews are the summaries above Google's results, built from pages that already rank for the search. AI Mode is a separate chat tab that runs its own searches and cites fewer pages. On our questions they agreed on a top pick on none of 40.
Does the list's author know?
Zapier's list says its placements aren't paid. Being cited by AI Mode is Google's choice, not the author's; what the author controls is who's on the list.
Does this hold in other categories?
We've measured one so far. The pattern, few pages per answer and the same ones across questions, is what lets one list dominate; check your own category's sources before acting on ours.
How fast does AI Mode pick up a change to a list?
We don't know yet. When a list we track adds or drops a product, we'll report how long AI Mode took to follow.
How we got these numbers
The 40 questions and every answer are public, a page each, on each assistant. Each question was asked once per assistant on November 11 and November 13, 2026, in the ChatGPT app, as a Google search and in Google AI Mode, logged out, from the US; Google's two sometimes finished the next day (UTC). We read each answer's recommended products and cited pages the same way for every assistant, and count two spellings of one product as one. Pages are compared by address without query strings. The same-question check uses only questions where an assistant cited the page in one round and not the other. Branded questions (“X alternatives”) are left out, as in the ranking.
Related: ChatGPT vs Google AI Mode · How ChatGPT picks and cites its sources · Best AI visibility tools
See which pages AI Mode cites for your product
The free checkup asks ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews and AI Mode 10 questions your buyers ask, in about 2 minutes, with every answer and the pages they cited.
100% free: no email, no sign-up, no credit card · Takes about 2 minutes